During a heavy snowstorm on March 9-10, 1860, the 250-ton brig Ewan Crerar struck Graves Ledge. The vessel anchored a short distance away as the crew tried to save the ship, but the Ewan Crerar sank within 45 minutes. No lives were lost.
Arriving in Boston from London, the brig bore a general cargo that included linseed oil, soda, colors, beer, whiting, steel, iron bars, horn, wool, cutch (used for dying and tanning leather), antimony and arsenic.
Robert F. Sullivan, in Shipwrecks and Nautical Lore of Boston Harbor, wrote:
“The pilot disclosed that he reached the bell buoy near the Graves and kept off, supposing he could clear the ledge. Because of a miscalculation or wind change, the vessel struck, became unmanageable, and was forced to anchor between Egg Rock and outer Brewster Island. She sank forty-five minutes later in seven fathoms, with only a few feet of her mainmast and topsail yard out of water. The rigging, sails, and spars were stripped from the brig. The crew abandoned ship, but were not in immediate danger.”
Divers salvaged much of the cargo.
The Ewan Crerar was built at the shipyard of James Kitchin, of River John, Nova Scotia, and launched in the spring of 1858.
Captain W. G. Crerar and Mrs. James Crerar of Pictou, Nova Scotia, were the proud owners.
They named the brig (also listed as a brigantine) after a relative, Captain Ewan Crerar, who went down with the barque Lord Ashburton on the Grand Manan Island, New Brunswick, in a winter storm the year before. (See Joseph Heard’s painting of the Lord Ashburton, above.)
For more, see:
BostonShipwrecks.org, Ewan Crerar page.
Edward Rowe Snow, The Islands of Boston Harbor, p. 194.